HEALTH NEWS
Local health news
National headlines
Alzheimer's news
Cancer news
Fitness news
Natural health news

 FEATURES
Columnists
Healthy living
Multimedia

 PROFESSIONALS
Local industry notes
National industry news
MV marketplace

 PARTNERS
uticaOD.com
uticaboilermaker.com
About us
 

Linda Brandwin, R.N.

Linda Brandwin is a registered nurse and a medical billing and claims specialist. For the past 10 years she has worked directly with insurance companies to give advice and guidance to the health care consumer.

Readers may send email or write Linda Brandwin at 5500 Single Oak Hill Ct., Woodbridge, VA 22192.

Overpayment on a bill entitles you to a refund
April 2, 2004

Q: My husband saw his doctor for his ankle. We overpaid the doctor's office before we realized that our primary and secondary insurance companies were also paying for the visit. I have called the doctor's office numerous times with no results. Finally I sent them a registered letter citing all of the payments made by us and our insurance companies. It is simple math…we and our insurance carriers paid them a total of $467.64. The final amount owed to the doctor's office as shown on our EOB is $252.99 which leaves a refund of $214.65 due to us. The office called me upon receipt of my letter and told me that as soon as they received the payment for my husband's last appointment they would refund the amount due us. My insurance carrier informed me that the doctor's office cashed that payment last week. I still have not heard anything from that office regarding a refund. I don't even know if their figures agree with mine. I can not get an intelligent response from them. We paid their bill in good faith within a week of receipt because I mistakenly thought that is what I owed. I thought getting a refund would take just a week also. Can you assist us?

A: I suspect your primary insurance paid their portion of the bill. You received an EOB, explanation of benefits, from them indicating the balance. You may have also received a bill from the doctor's office before they received payment from your secondary insurance company. You paid that balance and so did your secondary insurance company. You are entitled to a refund immediately. Your refund should not be tied into any other bills from other appointments. It is just a cleaner, simpler and a less complicated way of bookkeeping. Then if there is any problem with future claims, they can be dealt with separately. One problem won't depend on the other. Keeping the billing issues separate from each other will make deciphering multiple problems easier with future bills. Of course, if you agree to keep the overpayment in your account until the next bill is paid, make sure that that bill was processed and paid correctly.

You need to call the head of billing again. Tell her that you want to go over your billing immediately and you expect a refund within a week. If she can not resolve this for you, speak to the office manager. If there is still a problem, speak to the doctor. He may have no idea that there is a billing problem unless you inform him. You can also call your insurance company and if the doctor is in-network, they may be able to provide some recourse for you. A doctor's office may not keep your overpayment. If there is still a problem getting a refund, you can call your local state medical board and also your state health insurance board.

If the overpayment to the doctor's office is the result of overpayments by both you and the insurance companies, you are only entitled to a refund of the portion of the overpayment you made. The insurance company is entitled to their share of the overpayment. If and how they collect that refund is between your doctor's office and the insurance companies themselves. But you should not receive the insurance companies' overpayment. Going to the doctor should not be monetarily profitable for the patient.






mvHealth Advertising Directory
Arthritis Specialists
Martin Morell, M.D.

Board Certified Rheumatologist

Terry L. Smith, FNP-C
Judith A. Balch, FNP-C

Services
Lab Services, Infusion Suite, X-Ray Suite

122 Business Park Drive, Suite One
Utica, NY
315.724.5353

Great Lakes Dental
We are pleased to announce we have renewed our partipation with

Guardian
DentalGuard Preferred


Call today for an appointment
315.336.0494

107 E. Chestnut St, Rome,
in the Chestnut Commons

Digestive Disease Medicine of Central New York, L.L.P.
Specializes in All digestive problems and Cancer Prevention.
For more information Contact your family physician
If you do no thave a physician, you may call to make an appointment
110 Business Park Dr.
New Hartford
315.624.7000
301 Genesee St, Oneida
315.363.9183

John N. Kalil
Attorney At Law


Over 28 years of quality legal services.
Free Office Consulation


289 Genesee St
Utica, Ny
315.797.7959

ASPEN DENTAL
Smile more this
holiday season

Save up to $600 on new dentures
with our premium comfidents dentures.
Call today

1.877.ASPEN49
(1.877.277.3649)

Now Accepting New Patients in Utica

LautheranCare

Rehabilition,
inside and out
Its what's inside that makes us special


108 Utica Road
Clinton, NY
315.853.5515

Mohawk Valley Heart Institute

Good for your heart, Close to home
Faxton-St. Luke's Healthcare and St. Elizabeths Medical Center

To Advertise
Here
Call
315.792.5043

Weight Watchers

Watch Yourself Change
Introducing our
Turn Around Program

1.877.7.LOSE.IT




mvHealth.com is the local information resource on the Internet for health consumers and medical professionals in the Mohawk Valley region of upstate New York.
Published by uticaOD.com and the Observer-Dispatch.
Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service (updated 8/2/2001). Copyright ©2001 uticaOD.com/Observer-Dispatch.